Radical Change at Scale Starts with Respect

By John Tully and Joe DeStefano Insights

Implementation at scale is the missing piece in foundational learning

Over the past decades, rigorous testing and learning have produced close to a consensus on how to teach children to read: phonics-based instruction in the language children speak at home. The evidence now spans dozens of countries.

What we do not yet know is how to get whole education systems to do it at scale, at speed, and well enough that most children reach proficiency. That is an implementation problem, not a pedagogy problem, and it reaches far beyond education. Substantial money has gone into understanding delivery at scale. Unfortunately, the impact of that money has been much and their is much less consensus here. 

Still, we believe the evidence points to clear principles for what good delivery looks like. It shows in the results. We have known for years that change happens when it is made practical and scripted at its critical points, so that it is both technically and culturally rigorous. It then has to be run by supervisors and teams who are empowered to deliver within that rigorous frame, in the way that works for their context. Too often, we still do not do it.

Start with respect

If we had to pick one word for what moves a system, it would be respect. Not as a value statement, but as a working method. Programmes lose impact when people on the ground feel worked on rather than worked with: when the outside team does not appear to believe in government, or in the intelligence of the people in the room.

Respect is not a round of co-design workshops. It is a sense that external and internal partners truly believe in the mission and in the importance of their colleagues’ work. It is a clear view of what good looks like; a tightly scripted way of working together; and a practical sense of where to insist on standardization and where to encourage innovation. It does involve a role for “outsiders”, but their role is tightly specified, and involves working with the people at the table long-term.

These principles apply at every level. The “outsider” problem is also the ministry-to-region and region-to-school problem. Most teachers, most head teachers and most regional leads want to do a good job, but they don’t feel listened to, don’t feel they know what they are supposed to do, or, worse, both. So they carry on as before: teachers teach as they always have, and everyone else fills in forms and does admin. Give teachers a sense of what good looks like, why it matters, and support as they experiment to get there in a way that they believe works for them and their students, and most will innovate. Give supervisors practical data on variation across their schools, and information in language that makes sense to them on what is working, and most will grab it.

Then deliver, narrowly, and obsessively

The principles are simple:

  • Pick 1-2 priorities: say, early reading through phonics. Refuse to add numeracy or secondary school until you have clear evidence the approach is working.
  • Test them hard in two or three regions, not one. Provide ongoing support to teachers, and don’t work only with teachers: engage head teachers and regional leadership too.
  • Model the implementation, not the content. The evidence on phonics is settled. What needs proving is how a system adopts it.
  • Fit the pace, communications and decision-making to the political cycle (with a small p). If you need evidence in nine months to guarantee a second year, there is no point structuring a two-year pilot. Make sure you are set up to have those answers when you need them.
  • Throughout, aim for clarity rather than more communication. Say what is known, what is not, and when it will be settled.

Build back better

Aid for education is shrinking. USAID has withdrawn. Other bilateral donors are cutting back. The financing gap is real. But the retrenchment has also created a huge opportunity to work better, not just leaner: to transform the relationship between funder and government partner, and between external experts, head teachers and teachers.

Even if funding returns, we cannot afford for the answer to be a rebuild of the old model of externally run projects. Let’s fund the system’s capacity to manage implementation, and move at the speed human change allows and demands. Radical change at scale is possible. It starts with respect.